Credit Clarity: A Guide for Fair Tenant Screening

Finding the ideal tenant for your rental property is a top priority for many landlords.  However, getting the best-suited renters for your apartment can be a challenging task. This is why tenant credit transparency is really important. Through a tenant credit check, clarity emerges as past-due payments, growing debt, bankruptcies, collections, or judgments are revealed.

A potential tenant’s credit history can provide valuable information about their financial responsibility and ability to pay rent on time. Continue reading as this guide explains the role of credit reports in landlord screening, along with key considerations to keep in mind before getting started.

Purpose of Credit Reports in Tenant Screening 

How Credit Scores Indicate Financial Reliability

A high credit score often indicates healthy financial standing. It demonstrates responsible spending, debt management, and timely bill payment. A low score, on the other hand, can make you reevaluate your financial practices and enhance your financial discipline. In the United States, a credit score of 700 or higher is typically considered good, while scores below 630 are generally regarded as low. However, credit ratings differ by country. Better terms and reduced debt payments, more housing and job prospects, and advantages for long-term financial planning are all possible with a high credit score. 

Credit ratings are used by landlords to assess the likelihood that tenants will make their rent payments on schedule. The chances of a tenant getting a rental can be improved and even reduced with a high credit score. Bay Property Management Group Northern Virginia suggests considering other factors, such as rental history and references, when screening tenants. Multi-faceted, a higher score can often improve financial options, including the ability to qualify for an insurance policy. On the other hand, a low credit score may suggest that you will pay even more to borrow money, or that you might not be able to borrow any money at all due to a low borrowing score and/or less reliable financial history.

Difference between Soft & Hard Credit Checks

Soft credit checks are often done to provide credit or insurance quotes, to determine eligibility for credit cards, and by price comparison websites. Additionally, businesses you are already familiar with employ them to assist with background checks. When you look at your own credit record and score, you are performing a soft credit check. Soft credit searches do not affect your credit score, even though they analyze your credit report.

On the other hand, a hard credit check is finished when you apply for credit in full or use certain services that analyze your credit report and could affect your credit score. When you apply for a credit card, loan, or mortgage, a corporation will frequently run a hard credit check. When offering a service, such as a utility supply, rental property, or a mobile phone contract, it also manifests. Your credit score may temporarily drop if you apply for new credit or services, but it may rise over time if you use and manage your accounts sensibly. Companies cannot perform a hard credit check without first requesting your consent.

Legal & Ethical Considerations in Credit Screening 

1 Applying Credit Criteria Consistently

The legal and ethical duty to apply credit criteria consistently during credit screening is important for maintaining fairness, avoiding discrimination, and complying with applicable laws. Property managers use several factors when evaluating applicants, rather than relying solely on minimum credit scores. The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) requires landlords to obtain written permission before obtaining credit reports, provide copies of any credit reports if adverse action is taken, and follow specific guidelines for obtaining and using credit data.

The Equal Opportunity Housing/Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, national origin, family status, or disability. Credit screening criteria should be used consistently for all applicants without bias or favoritism. Landlords are also subject to specific regional laws regarding credit screening to protect applicants’ rights. Additionally, screening should not, in any way, exclude, screen, or treat applicants differently based on protected classes or arbitrary factors.

Applying identical credit standards to all applicants guarantees consistent transparency, equality, and fairness in decision-making. All decisions should examine the applicant’s complete financial picture, rather than relying solely on the credit score or a single negative item in isolation. If a landlord or lender denies an application based on credit, they are required to provide clear reasons and should allow applicants to obtain their report and dispute any inaccuracy.

2. Maintaining Transparency with Applicants

Transparency refers to making clear and accessible information available to the applicant concerning the credit check process, how the information will be used, and whether the applicant is aware of their rights. In the United States, and in other countries with similar data protection legislation, such as the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), the employer or landlord must notify the applicant of the intention to conduct a credit check, give them a clear disclosure, and obtain their written consent before proceeding with the credit check.

If credit information leads to an adverse action, the applicant must receive a pre-adverse action notice that includes the credit report and any summary of their rights to litigate the accuracy of their credit information. This scenario usually comes from having an applicant being denied a job or housing. If that negative decision is final, then the employer or landlord must send a formal notice of adverse action to the applicant, advising them of the name of the credit reporting agency they can contact and a summary of their rights.

Transparency fosters trust and fairness by enabling applicants to understand the standards and processes involved in decisions that affect them. Therefore, applicants should be aware of the reasoning behind automated decision-making processes, including the factors that affect their credit score.

From an ethical standpoint, a company must balance transparency with the protection of sensitive data and trade secrets, but cannot be fully transparent about everything with applicants. However, allowing applicants an opportunity to review and rebut information fosters fairness and helps minimize errors in credit assessments.

How to Explain Credit-Related Rejections Fairly?

In order to provide a fair explanation for a credit-related denial, it is important to communicate clearly, within a timely manner, and in a specific manner to the applicant about the basis for the denial, all while being mindful of your legal obligations. 

One option to express this is through the use of an Adverse Action Notice. Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (“FCRA”) and the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (“ECOA”), where a credit denial has been made based upon information in a credit report, an applicant is entitled to a written notice of adverse action. The notice must state the reasons for the denial or the applicant’s right to request those reasons. The creditor’s notification must be done within a reasonable time period, usually no later than 30 days after receiving a completed credit application, at which point the credit was denied. 

The notice must communicate the principal reasons for the denial in plain and non-technical language. Examples include an applicant with an adverse payment history, a high debt-to-credit ratio, or an inadequate credit history. Notify applicants that they have the option to receive a free copy of their credit report from the reporting agency that provided the information and that they can challenge the information if they do not agree with the content. Avoid overly technical jargon, but share a level of discussion that is just right so the applicant understands the basis for the determination. However, do not disclose the proprietary scoring formula, which may be considered sensitive information.  

Final Thoughts 

Examining the findings of tenant screening essentially entails a thorough review of references, credit reports, and background checks. It’s a good idea to always follow the rental guidelines and keep up with your legal obligations. A positive rental experience depends on effective tenant management, so it’s best to continue refining your screening techniques to achieve optimal results.

Verify that your decision complies with ethical and legal requirements. Discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, national origin, family status, or handicap is prohibited by the Fair Housing Act. Each applicant must undergo a consistent evaluation process, and any decisions must be supported by the established screening criteria. When making decisions, use the information and respect the law, rather than relying solely on your intuition.

---